The Scent of Water ★★★✫ 3 & 1/2
By Elizabeth Goudge, 1963

I’ve changed my reviewing method. This is a full star, , and this a half star, 

★★★★ Not to miss, worth re-reading
★★★★    Books that surely have stayed with me.
★★★       Very enjoyable read, recommendable.
★★          Meh. Nothing remarkable.
★             Run.

The half star, , would make it closer to the higher category, an in-between of sorts.

This is one of the books I’m reading with my friend Kim, and also a title I listed for the 5 year Classics Bookclub.

I first met Elizabeth Goudge through the curriculum book lists at Ambleside Online. Her book for children, The Little White Horse is pretty well known, and the girls and I enjoyed it. Her other books for adults (which can be read by young adults too), have become quite popular among circles of readers and friends around me. I read The Rosemary Tree, and it was OK. Not a wow title, but charming. I liked the way she portrays children, and I enjoyed her mentions of Don Quijote in regards to friendship, and as one of the favorite books of one of her characters.

When Kim suggested (or was I?), to read The Scent of Water, it felt as a good reading title.

I started reading it during Harvey, but I couldn’t focus much on reading, and the book starts a bit slow. It wasn’t that bad as to abandon it, so I persisted. And I’m glad I did. In time, Goudge immerses the reader in the happenings of a small country district where the protagonist goes to live. Mary Lindsay had her auntie’s name. She visited her auntie only once, when she was young (eight years old, I think.) Mary was mesmerized by a collection of small things her aunt had. Among it, there was a miniature carriage with Queen Mab, and a blue china set. Despite not knowing her other than for that short day, her aunt leaves her the place and a bit of inheritance. When Mary retires, she decides to leave London’s noise and buzz in favor of the countryside. There she’ll meet the vicar, his sister, and the locals. She’ll meet the family that lives back to back with her, and their three children, one of them, Edith, adopted.  Through the people she’ll get to know the past, the secrets and afflictions they bear, and be a positive part of their future.

Elizabeth Goudge could be described as an inspirational writer. For the most part, I find these so called christian books contrived, and they do not ignite, not even spark my moral imagination at all. However, Goudge doesn’t write a book to convey a christian message, she has a story to tell, and her characters are well crafted. They are credible. The reflections and thoughts she gives the reader here and there, are not preachy, but they were my favorite parts. It was like listening to an old friend talking about the nature of love, loss, childhood, mental illness, marriage, etc.

My verdict: easy to read yet full of deep thoughts. Pick it up if you want to be transported to the countryside of England, and if you want to know about a few interesting people and how they navigate the storms of life.

This is a quote from the part when Mary is talking about Paul. A parishioner who became blind in the Great War.

The question shot out at her with a directness which she might have thought rude had she not already begun intuitively to understand this man. Suffering had had an effect with which she was familiar. The refusal of self-pity and despair had turned it from lead to fire, burning up the subterfuges and dishonesties below the surface of the inherited veneer of manners and thought that most men and women think are their true selves, and the veneer with them. He was forged now all of one piece, as he and the dog were of one piece, and spoke as he thought, rude or not. The blindness had helped perhaps. She imagined that if you were blind you must either live shut within yourself or seek with others a true and honest communication. Nothing else would be much use in the dark.

9 thoughts on “The Scent of Water

  1. What a great, succinct review. I love hearing this from your perspective as I think you and I are bit different readers. Yes, Christian fiction. Ugh. I KEEP trying different titles that come to me through recommendations etc, but still haven’t found anything very good recently, I’m eternally optimistic that someday there will be something good in that genre. I feel a bit sheepish when so critical of them, because I love to write and have a teeny picture of how hard it is to write anything even a little remotely good. I tend to read inspirational/Christian fiction when I’m at my absolute most exhausted and don’t want to do any mental work. Not sure it’s the best idea, but I do end up doing that. I’ve been working really hard this year to choose better things to read when exhausted because time is precious. It has been so good. Goudge is one of my current four favorite authors. 🙂 I suspect they are fluffy compared to yours! LOL! 🙂 Austen, Montgomery, Taber, and Goudge is the list. But that’s why I love you, you challenge and inspire me! Continuing to think of you! ❤ Amy

    Liked by 1 person

    1. LOL. She is not fluffy at all, hers is a beautiful simplicity. I love how different we are. I also feel a tad guilty when criticizing Christian fiction, because I understand they are great books for so many. And I recognize your need for something easy when you are exhausted. I watch TV when I’m exhausted, 🙂 I watch Kitchen Nightmares, some movies… I don’t think all our reading should be in the ‘challenge’ area. Denser books seem to relax me too at times, for I find it very stimulating to read things that are philosophical, etc. This book was a balm to me. It was enjoyable, yet she had something valuable and truly christian to offer. I do love to compare and contrast. I still believe you are hard with yourself, ha ha ha. I’m glad though you are choosing better withing yourself. (I too think this year I’ve been choosing books that have been wonderful, I have not felt I’ve wasted my time with any title.)

      Liked by 1 person

  2. So happy you finished the book! I’m in the middle of it and moving along 🙂 Hoping to finish by the end of the month. Goudge has been doing a good job of transporting me to her little home and garden. Looking forward to finishing!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I have only read The Rosemary Tree and I quite liked it. I am not Christian, but as you mention, her books are more inspiration than overtly moralistic or preachy. I like having authors like this in my “back pocket”, where you can read them if you need a known quantity: something gentle and worth reading, but not overly taxing.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I like that, “something gentle and worth reading, but not overly taxing”
      I agree with you, I like her books, they give you so much in a gentle way. They are also great for all of us who love parish like books, and the British countryside of the last century.


  4. I still haven’t got around to reading anything by Goudge. My girls loved The Little White Horse, which I haven’t read…I’ve had The Rosemary Tree sitting on my bookshelf for some time but I’ve never felt in the mood to start it. I recently changed my email address and realised I hadn’t been getting updates from your blog. Will remedy that now…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So much to read, and so little time, right? She is rewarding, you’d love her whenever you get a chance to read her books.
      (Thanks so much for subscribing to the blog, I always love to hear you here or at yours.)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.